Can you protect a toy? How the Lego brick helped build the case law
In January 1958, the Danish company Lego filed a patent for a small plastic brick with studs on top and tubes underneath. The interlocking system was ingenious, and it would make the company’s fortune. But patents do not last forever: once a patent expires, any manufacturer can produce bricks that fit together. Lego then looked for other ways to keep its monopoly over the brick: trademarks, designs, copyright. Half a century of litigation later, the brick has become a textbook case for toy manufacturers wondering what they can protect.
The answer comes down to one idea: each element of a toy calls for its own tool. Functional shape, appearance, character and name are not protected in the same way. And with the year-end launches approaching, the order in which you proceed matters as much as the choice of tool.
The technical shape of a toy cannot become a trademark
The temptation to protect the shape of a toy through trademark law is understandable. A trademark can be renewed indefinitely, whereas a patent or a design expires. Registering the shape of the toy as a trademark would amount to obtaining a never-ending monopoly.
The law, however, closes that door. A sign consisting exclusively of the shape of goods which is necessary to obtain a technical result cannot be registered as a trademark1. The rule is specifically designed to prevent a manufacturer from using trademark law to extend a monopoly that belongs to patent law, as illustrated by the CERAMTEC case law I discussed last week in my article on registering color marks.
Lego learned this the hard way too. Its three-dimensional trademark representing the red brick was canceled, and the Court of Justice upheld the cancellation in 2010: the essential characteristics of the brick perform a technical function, and the fact that other shapes could achieve the same result makes no difference2.
The Rubik’s Cube met the same fate. The Court of Justice first criticized the General Court for failing to take into account the actual function of the product, the rotation of its faces, by analyzing only the graphic representation of the mark3. When the case came back before it, the General Court confirmed the invalidity of the shape mark: the grid structure on the faces of the cube is necessary for that rotation4.
A shape mark remains an option for a toy whose appearance has no technical function, such as a figurine or a soft toy. However, it requires the public to perceive that shape as an indication of commercial origin, which is rare in practice.
Designs: the natural choice for toys
To protect the appearance of a toy, a design is the most suitable tool. Two conditions are enough: novelty and individual character. The latter is assessed by reference to the overall visual impression produced on the informed user, taking into account the designer’s degree of freedom5.
Applications are filed on the INPI website for France, or on the EUIPO website for the whole of the European Union. Protection runs for five-year periods, renewable up to twenty-five years6. A single application can cover several designs from the same range, which may appeal to manufacturers who offer a toy in several versions and allow them to achieve economies of scale.
Timing matters. A design disclosed before it is filed in principle loses its novelty. The law does, however, grant a twelve-month grace period where the disclosure comes from the designer themselves7. Showing a prototype at a trade fair in January and filing in November therefore remains possible. It is nevertheless advisable to file before any presentation: the grace period protects against your own disclosure, not against a competitor who may have filed a similar design in the meantime.
EU law also protects, for three years, an unregistered design disclosed within the European Union8. This protection only applies against copying and is harder to enforce. For a flagship holiday-season product, it is no substitute for a registration.
Construction pieces: the modular exception
Construction sets raise a particular difficulty. Design law in principle excludes shapes that must be reproduced exactly to allow one product to be connected to another. But the law provides for an exception: a design intended to allow the multiple assembly or connection of interchangeable products within a modular system can be protected9.
This exception was written for products such as the Lego brick. In 2021, the EU General Court annulled the EUIPO decision that had invalidated the design of a Lego brick. The Office had failed to examine the modular exception and had not taken into account all the features of appearance of the brick, including the smooth surface on either side of the row of studs10.
The Court of Justice clarified the scope of this protection in 202511. The court compares the pieces from the perspective of an informed user, who is attentive and familiar with products in the sector, not from that of a technical expert examining every detail. Connection points of the same shape and dimensions are included in this comparison and may prevent a finding that the overall impression is different.
The same decision closes another loophole. The manufacturer of a construction set cannot escape the prohibition on the ground that the disputed pieces make up only a small part of the set12. For a manufacturer of compatible bricks, the practical takeaway is that compatibility is allowed, but the appearance of the pieces must differ visibly from that of the protected designs.
Characters and figurines fall under copyright
A character, a figurine or a soft toy can be protected by copyright, without any registration, provided it is original13. This protection lasts for the author’s lifetime and seventy years from 1 January of the year following their death. It can be combined with a registered design14.
The Court of Justice recently clarified the conditions for this protection in relation to utilitarian objects15. No stricter requirement applies to works of applied art. The object must reflect its author’s personality through free and creative choices. To establish infringement, it is enough that creative elements of the work are reproduced in a recognisable way.
In practice, the originality of a toy must be demonstrated in court, element by element. Designers should keep their sketches, successive versions and exchanges with the manufacturer, dated and filed. These are the documents that will make it possible to explain the creative choices if a dispute ever arises.
Names and brand universes are protected by trademarks
The name of the toy, the name of the range and the logo are protected by registering a trademark. The application should cover Class 28 of the Nice Classification, which covers games and toys. If the toy comes with an app, an animated series or merchandise, the application must be extended to the corresponding classes.
Clearance searches are essential before any filing. The toy sector is saturated with short, playful names that are close to one another, and an opposition received a few weeks before the product launch may force the manufacturer to reprint its packaging and overhaul its entire marketing plan.
LAZULI advises toy designers, manufacturers and distributors on protecting their creations: choosing the right tool for each element of the product, filing designs and trademarks in France and the European Union, pre-launch clearance searches, and action against copies. Contact the firm to review your next range.
Jérémie LEROY-RINGUET, October 2026
- Art. L. 711-2(5) of the French Intellectual Property Code (CPI); for the EU trademark, Art. 7(1)(e)(ii) of Regulation (EU) 2017/1001 ↩︎
- CJEU, September 14, 2010, Lego Juris v OHIM, C‑48/09 P, ECLI:EU:C:2010:516 ↩︎
- CJEU, November 10, 2016, Simba Toys v EUIPO, C‑30/15 P ↩︎
- EU General Court, October 24, 2019, Rubik’s Brand v EUIPO, T‑601/17 ↩︎
- Arts L. 511-2 and L. 511-4 CPI ↩︎
- Art. L. 513-1 CPI ↩︎
- Art. L. 511-6 CPI ↩︎
- Art. 11 of Council Regulation (EC) No 6/2002 of December 12, 2001 on Community designs, as amended by Regulation (EU) 2024/2822 of October 23, 2024 ↩︎
- Art. L. 511-8 CPI; Art. 8(3) of Regulation (EC) No 6/2002 ↩︎
- EU General Court, March 24, 2021, Lego v EUIPO, T‑515/19, paras 84 and 105 to 107 ↩︎
- CJEU, September 4, 2025, Lego v Pozitív Energiaforrás, C‑211/24, ECLI:EU:C:2025:648, paras 50 to 54 ↩︎
- Ibid., paras 66 and 67 ↩︎
- Arts L. 111-1, L. 112-2(7) and (10), and L. 123-1 CPI ↩︎
- Art. L. 513-2 CPI ↩︎
- CJEU, December 4, 2025, Mio and Others and Konektra, C‑580/23 and C‑795/23 ↩︎
